Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Harry checks out Kimberly Pierce's STOP-LOSS

Films about our current situation in Iraq are not necessarily why we go to movie theaters. We’ve seen recent films on Iraq fail repeatedly at the box office and there is a reason. We generally go to theaters to escape reality, not to confront it. Right now there’s a goodly portion of the current election hinging on a stance regarding what we do in Iraq. There is no easy answer.

Most of the films we’ve seen have been documentaries about the various atrocities that are taking place in this war. Films like the one Brian DePalma made. Films that do not raise our estimation of our young men and women fighting everyday thousands of miles from where we are today?

Kimberly Peirce has made a film that isn’t about the terrible situation in Iraq. The soldiers depicted in this situation are men trying to do their job as best they know how to do. Shit does go down – and that shit is not the stuff of happiness, but it isn’t the sort of thing that makes us think worse of our soldiers.

The soldiers in Pierce’s film are short – they’re coming home. They’re from small town Texas – and after a very powerful opening where some men lose their lives and limbs… well its time for them to go home.

For Ryan Phillipe and Channing Tatum’s characters of Brandon and Steve… it’s time to go home. Brandon is looking forward to moving on with his life. And Steve? Well, he’s going to marry his fiancé, played by Abbie Cornish. These aren’t complicated people. They signed up for the military to fight and protect their country’s interest. They don’t feel the government owes them anything. They’re just ready to continue their post service life. They’ve done their bit for flag and country.

Then on the day where they turn in their gear and they’re supposed to get their discharge papers – they learn a new word for the day… STOP LOSS. The term STOP LOSS isn’t new in the military – and the current administration isn’t the first to use its authority to extend soldiers term of service. STOP LOSS came about after the draft was stopped. And it was first used during the first Gulf War by the first President Bush – and has been used during every military engagement from the first Gulf War – through Bosnia all the way to the engagements we are in today.

Ryan’s Brandon does not accept being STOP LOSS’d. Something happened on that final mission that shot his nerves, that made him no longer wish to be in charge of men in a combat situation. He doesn’t want people maimed and killed under his command – and moreso… he feels that this isn’t right. That he was being shafted by his country – and he was going to fight it.

The situation gets bad, right from the get go. We end up learning that there is apparently an underground railroad for getting service men in this situation to Canada or Mexico. The film paints a desperate situation for Ryan’s Brandon. Not only that, but Channing’s Steve decides to reenlist so he can get sniper training so he can choose his method of service – and this causes strife between him and his fiancé.

The story of STOP LOSS is a powerful modern military story. It doesn’t judge the war, nor does it paint our politicians in a good or evil light. Rather, the film shows the situation for our soldiers that get caught up in this system as being in a bad situation.

There are no solutions, no proposals made. This film is realistic and the choices are actually fairly simple for a soldier in this situation. They go back to Iraq.

The film, STOP LOSS, is a pro-soldier film about an unfair situation that many of our military men are in. Without a draft – and without high enlistment numbers… the policy of STOP LOSS will continue – not just through Iraq, but through any military engagement that occurs during a soldier’s time of service. It simply is the policy that exists in our modern military. You can learn more about it: here!

So how is the movie? The performances and the direction are excellent. This is a mature film with solid performances across the board. Nobody is dressed up to be an easy villain – and nobody is dumbed down to be a fool. The situation is what it is.

With BOYS DON’T CRY and now STOP LOSS – Kimberly Peirce continues her rather intimate story-telling. The situation isn’t pretty in either film. One dealing with sexual issues in America – and this one dealing with military service issues. She tackles both with a very sharp emotional point of view. These characters are alive and strong – and the situations… real.

There are ads on television that would have you believe this is a film about a military romance. That it’s a sweet story. Those elements are here, but be forewarned, this is a film about a situation that isn’t happy or cheery. Don’t look for fairy tale endings, because this story is about a situation that is sad for our soldiers – and one that doesn’t make you feel good about how they’re treated by the government.

That said, this is a film that will improve with time. It’s a very good film. Just hard to watch with the knowledge that this IS what is happening right now. That’s hard to escape while watching this story. But then, this isn’t a movie to escape reality, but to confront it and to expose it.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback

First!
by EvilGeek1
Mar 20th, 2008
10:22:00 PM
So this is nothing like RAMBO?
by ABking
Mar 20th, 2008
10:23:24 PM
second?
by bob oblaw
Mar 20th, 2008
10:23:26 PM
The films about Iraq have failed...
by poeticwarriorII
Mar 20th, 2008
10:26:09 PM
RAMBO V needs a synopsis...
by poeticwarriorII
Mar 20th, 2008
10:27:55 PM
Can moriarty please review this movie
by IndustryKiller!
Mar 20th, 2008
10:28:15 PM
Heavy handed?
by Mr. Gunderson
Mar 20th, 2008
10:29:07 PM
"The soldiers in Pierce’s film are short"
by Bobo_Vision
Mar 20th, 2008
10:34:45 PM
The film is likely to flop, like the other Iraq themed films hav
by BDuncan
Mar 20th, 2008
10:36:47 PM
Wow...
by expert40
Mar 20th, 2008
10:40:29 PM
WORST "president" in History
by GrendelGrendelGrendel
Mar 20th, 2008
10:42:58 PM
All this other bullshit aside...
by poeticwarriorII
Mar 20th, 2008
10:46:45 PM
When oh when...
by TroutMaskReplicant
Mar 20th, 2008
10:49:19 PM
I really wanted to see this this weekend...
by 23GreatWoundsAllGotInBattle
Mar 20th, 2008
10:51:28 PM
The entire premise of this movie is idiotic...
by critch
Mar 20th, 2008
10:55:36 PM
Grendel, you're full of shit...
by expert40
Mar 20th, 2008
10:57:43 PM
critch...
by expert40
Mar 20th, 2008
11:01:41 PM
Yeah, but...
by 23GreatWoundsAllGotInBattle
Mar 20th, 2008
11:01:48 PM
Iraq is
by Mezzanine
Mar 20th, 2008
11:08:41 PM
Re: 23GreatWoundsAllGotInBattle
by jjwspider
Mar 20th, 2008
11:13:50 PM
CHENEY SPENT THE FIVE YEAR ANNIVERSARY
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 20th, 2008
11:21:45 PM
Israelis are no saints though...
by 23GreatWoundsAllGotInBattle
Mar 20th, 2008
11:23:11 PM
I read the boards to get my political knowledge, don't you?
by LilBuddy
Mar 20th, 2008
11:26:22 PM
JJWSPIDER
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 20th, 2008
11:29:11 PM
LET THE BODIES HIT THE FLOOR!
by Osmosis Jones
Mar 20th, 2008
11:35:22 PM
CRITCH
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 20th, 2008
11:35:55 PM
BSB the apologist
by Sir Loin
Mar 20th, 2008
11:38:09 PM
Good Review Harry
by Turd Furgeson
Mar 20th, 2008
11:44:03 PM
23GreatWoundsAllGotInBattle
by jjwspider
Mar 20th, 2008
11:45:43 PM
One BRAT's opinion
by FlyinHawaiian30
Mar 20th, 2008
11:47:58 PM
Cont...
by FlyinHawaiian30
Mar 20th, 2008
11:49:47 PM
SIR LOIN
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 20th, 2008
11:52:01 PM
I didn't know Kimberly Pierce directed
by kafka07
Mar 21st, 2008
12:14:15 AM
This movie will tank
by Choo
Mar 21st, 2008
12:30:29 AM
Switzerland
by lazy13
Mar 21st, 2008
12:31:37 AM
You know what i love?
by cathartist
Mar 21st, 2008
12:41:42 AM
Hey jjwspider...
by 23GreatWoundsAllGotInBattle
Mar 21st, 2008
01:10:37 AM
www.aint-it-liberal-propaganda .com
by uss cygnus
Mar 21st, 2008
01:56:15 AM
THE ONLY GOOD DESERTER...
by uss cygnus
Mar 21st, 2008
01:57:02 AM
YOU CAN'T STOP IT, AND THAT'S WHAT PISSES YOU OFF.
by uss cygnus
Mar 21st, 2008
01:59:36 AM
THE ONLY "ATROCITY" IS THE LIBERAL PROPAGANDA SPOUTED BY THIS WE
by uss cygnus
Mar 21st, 2008
02:04:33 AM
Just saw Redacted
by Series7
Mar 21st, 2008
02:04:59 AM
Commercials look like a CW teen drama
by skywalkerfamily
Mar 21st, 2008
02:34:48 AM
i will review soon...
by The Real MiraJeff
Mar 21st, 2008
02:58:47 AM
No websites, buddy...
by 23GreatWoundsAllGotInBattle
Mar 21st, 2008
03:03:57 AM
Reviews go in news...
by Tourist
Mar 21st, 2008
05:03:36 AM
Critch, read the review...
by Tourist
Mar 21st, 2008
05:11:20 AM
Matt Damon's doing an Iraq themed film called Green Zone
by Greg7007
Mar 21st, 2008
06:18:46 AM
STOP! IN THE NAME OF LOSS
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 21st, 2008
06:43:29 AM
NOT CRITCH - I MEANT 23GREATWOUNDSALLGOTINTOBATTLE
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 21st, 2008
06:48:10 AM
USS CYGNUS
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 21st, 2008
06:51:24 AM
Israel is a nuisance...
by Tourist
Mar 21st, 2008
07:07:22 AM
Also...
by Tourist
Mar 21st, 2008
07:13:30 AM
Ugh...
by Fah-Cue
Mar 21st, 2008
07:30:58 AM
STOP! Or my Mom will Shoot.
by Senator John McCain
Mar 21st, 2008
07:56:19 AM
Tourist...
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
08:10:21 AM
aintitliberal
by maddox
Mar 21st, 2008
08:18:16 AM
America Sucks .
by Papa Lazaru
Mar 21st, 2008
08:26:42 AM
...oh, and on the actuall facts of this movie...
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
08:28:42 AM
er...'actual facts'...
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
08:30:25 AM
DiPalma's Film wasn't a documentary, Harry
by DevilCat
Mar 21st, 2008
08:36:48 AM
are you shitting me?
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
08:38:42 AM
Bill Brasky...
by KosherWookie
Mar 21st, 2008
08:51:55 AM
"fucking conservative fuckbags" = prime example
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
08:59:04 AM
KosherWookie
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
09:01:42 AM
BILL BRASKY
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 21st, 2008
09:04:34 AM
I believe Bushwick Bill said it best when he said...
by Kentucky Colonel
Mar 21st, 2008
09:19:07 AM
BSB...
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
09:30:43 AM
Spoiler Tag?
by PotSmokinAlien
Mar 21st, 2008
09:31:15 AM
'Stop Loss' Marketing Campaign
by Lone_Wolf_McQuaalude
Mar 21st, 2008
09:31:18 AM
Bill Brasky
by Series7
Mar 21st, 2008
09:39:18 AM
PotSmokingAlien
by Bobo_Vision
Mar 21st, 2008
09:44:07 AM
No Mention of JGL?
by SpawnofAchilles
Mar 21st, 2008
09:48:50 AM
SK229
by Series7
Mar 21st, 2008
09:49:41 AM
I've only ever seen the ads on MTV
by Jackie Boy
Mar 21st, 2008
09:56:35 AM
The TV ads make this flick look like 2Fast 2Furious...
by FlickaPoo
Mar 21st, 2008
10:03:35 AM
You mean this isn't 2 Hard For the Guard?
by Series7
Mar 21st, 2008
10:07:14 AM
The next Iraq War Movie should be called...
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
10:07:27 AM
Oh, and BringingSexyBack...
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
10:09:31 AM
Series7
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
10:14:22 AM
The first great Iraq war film will surely be....
by waggy
Mar 21st, 2008
10:19:13 AM
...so SK229, I guess you are trying to say that...
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
10:25:46 AM
"AMERIKKKA..."
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
10:26:47 AM
I don't believe Harry wrote this review AT ALL
by Bass Bastardson
Mar 21st, 2008
10:27:31 AM
harry, that actually sounded like
by Lloyd Bonafide the Korean War Veteran
Mar 21st, 2008
10:41:47 AM
EXECUTE GENERAL ORDER 69
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 21st, 2008
10:48:23 AM
Yes, good stuff
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
11:49:27 AM
Fewer crimes than average
by maddox
Mar 21st, 2008
12:00:40 PM
Subject matter
by caerlas
Mar 21st, 2008
12:27:26 PM
Real Perspective
by NemesisNY
Mar 21st, 2008
01:19:41 PM
GO1 and its pros/cons
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
01:44:43 PM
Right on Brother!
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
02:08:06 PM
Brasky...
by Tourist
Mar 21st, 2008
04:11:51 PM
Last I heard our Army was volunteer
by skywalkerfamily
Mar 21st, 2008
04:30:47 PM
When McCain becomes Pres we'll be going to
by skywalkerfamily
Mar 21st, 2008
06:32:41 PM
Agreed that the marketing is flawed
by The Winged Doucheman
Mar 21st, 2008
07:04:37 PM
This movie is a fraud!
by sign1in
Mar 21st, 2008
08:00:40 PM
SoylentMean
by Bill Brasky
Mar 21st, 2008
09:18:58 PM
NemesisNY
by jjwspider
Mar 21st, 2008
09:57:03 PM
Soylent Man
by NemesisNY
Mar 21st, 2008
11:05:59 PM
I support the troops...
by ebonic_plague
Mar 21st, 2008
11:55:21 PM
JJWSPIDER
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 22nd, 2008
01:42:16 AM
BILL BRASKY
by BringingSexyBack
Mar 22nd, 2008
02:05:52 AM
They aren't surrounded by enemies because...
by Tourist
Mar 22nd, 2008
02:07:34 AM
Now if this film had werewolves...
by Uncle Stan
Mar 22nd, 2008
07:38:25 AM
Ebonic_Plague
by NemesisNY
Mar 22nd, 2008
09:59:01 AM
Nemesis
by ebonic_plague
Mar 22nd, 2008
11:54:21 AM
BringingSexyBack
by jjwspider
Mar 22nd, 2008
12:36:21 PM
Werewolves, I say. Werewolves.
by Uncle Stan
Mar 22nd, 2008
02:43:27 PM
Ebonic
by NemesisNY
Mar 22nd, 2008
02:49:48 PM
Nemesis
by ebonic_plague
Mar 22nd, 2008
03:31:04 PM
If only this movie had Transformers
by skywalkerfamily
Mar 22nd, 2008
04:08:50 PM
Oh, and...
by ebonic_plague
Mar 22nd, 2008
04:20:23 PM
Ebonic
by NemesisNY
Mar 22nd, 2008
05:32:22 PM
Nick Berg and Wrong Place/Wrong Time.
by Tourist
Mar 22nd, 2008
10:44:25 PM
Tourist
by NemesisNY
Mar 22nd, 2008
11:11:44 PM
"STOP-LOSS"? Yeah, nobody'll see this movie!
by MrMysteryGuest
Mar 22nd, 2008
11:21:16 PM
Ever hear of Chechyna?
by Tourist
Mar 23rd, 2008
01:01:40 AM
Palestinians are semitic...
by PurityOfEssence
Mar 24th, 2008
05:31:56 AM
Expose What?
by richiro33
Mar 24th, 2008
09:05:59 PM
lol
by slkboxrman
Mar 25th, 2008
12:46:35 AM
Any war scenes?
by Dazzler69
Mar 25th, 2008
07:05:01 AM
IT'S PEIRCE, NOT PIERCE
by polyh3dron
Mar 27th, 2008
12:32:46 AM
STOP! OR MY MOM WILL LOSS
by polyh3dron
Mar 27th, 2008
12:34:54 AM
Our president lied to start this war
by MattmanReturns
Mar 28th, 2008
01:20:18 PM
The Public has Spoken
by richiro33
Mar 29th, 2008
10:38:23 AM
Hey Slk
by TheGreatBowdini
Mar 30th, 2008
05:04:43 PM
p.s.
by TheGreatBowdini
Mar 30th, 2008
05:07:37 PM
war
by novembre13
Apr 1st, 2008
03:35:33 PM
i agree
by TheGreatBowdini
Apr 2nd, 2008
12:30:32 PM
the reality of it
by theangiechrist
Jun 4th, 2008
02:02:55 PM
and also
by theangiechrist
Jun 4th, 2008
02:03:49 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.